Welcome
Welcome to physicsdiscussionforum

You are currently viewing our boards as a guest, which gives you limited access to view most discussions and access our other features. By joining our free community, you will have access to post topics, communicate privately with other members (PM), respond to polls, upload content, and access many other special features. In addition, registered members also see less advertisements. Registration is fast, simple, and absolutely free, so please, join our community today!

Gravity Angular momentum equivalence

Gravity Angular momentum equivalence

Postby grandpawo » Wed Mar 15, 2017 6:01 pm

Space-Time [Compression-Dilation]

Elementary Physics Disciples, please take a few minutes to evaluate the following short story. (Now also note the Time Twin Paradox at the end) Gravity=Centripetal Acceleration.

Suppose Anoman and Znoman (Identical Twins) are in deep space living on opposite sides of a hollow planet with the same radius and mass of Earth, but mass is concentrated in a very thin crust (Note; nothing else exists in the universe as they can see). They of course experience a normal g force just like on Earth. Now suppose each of them cuts a small diameter worm-hole and look inside, and Znoman sees Anoman on the other side. Znoman gently lowers himself into the hole and experiences no g force at all. He is weightless. So he kicks off the rim of his hole and sails effortlessly through the center of the planet to Anoman on the other side. Once there, Anoman helps Znoman a little to stand up and Znoman experiences 1 g again standing there with Anoman.
Anoman has been playing with rocket engines and demonstrates one to Znoman. It is mounted level with the surface which is tangent. Anoman turns it on and immediately they feel a slight force in the direction of the rocket exhaust, but not so much as they can still stand comfortably and talk. They talk and talk for days and have absolutely no idea their planet is rotating from the effects of the rocket, since there are no other bodies in the universe to relate. They began noticing during the lengthy conversation that they did not feel as heavy, and after several days began to levitate. Znoman said, “Turn off that rocket engine, it must be doing something”. They have no idea what has happened. They just float around on the surface, like magic carpets. They can carry a whole tree effortlessly for an entire season of firewood. Well, Znoman says, “I really need to be getting back to my side of the planet”.
But, BIG problem! When Znoman starts to enter the opening, and go back inside the hollow planet, he feels his weight again pushing him back to the surface. Finally, he manages to get inside and try kicking off the rim. He only travels a couple of feet and then pushed back. He could walk around the inside crust, but that is, half the circumference of the planet, approximately 12,500 miles while experiencing 1 g! So, he comes back up out of the hole and then floats around the outer surface by pulling on tree limbs to get back to his side of the planet.
They ponder for days, weeks and years and cannot explain that force of 1g pushing them out of the hole and back out to the 0 g home surface. From the story you can see that from their limited dimensions and perspective, they can in no way determine that they are rotating.
Now, please reduce the hollow planet to a very thin hollow ring say 1 meter wide, with mass and radius of Earth while doing the same exercises, with the (through inside center) visit, and rocket engine, and keeping the crawl holes on opposite ends of the ring’s diameter, giving a plane two-dimensional universe. Observations will be the same.
Now, suppose their clones just magically came aboard the 2 dimensional universe. Anoman and Znoman got old and checked out, and taught them nothing of previous experiences. Therefore, they must learn Physics the old fashion way, by observations. Remember, they are at zero g outside the ring and as they enter the hole they experience a repulsive force pushing them back out of the hole. If they manage to get inside they feel a force of one g, perpendicular to the inside of the ring. If they picked up a rock and dropped it, they would measure an acceleration of 9.8m/sec^2, toward their feet and the inside of the ring.

Elementary Physics Disciples: Please note that your thinking is being baited to give you a broader application with mathematical proofs. First taking some elementary Trig and Algebra with a little Integral Calculus and the inverse square law and we easily prove that the gravitational field is zero inside the ring. Now use vector- tensor analysis to show a space compression and time dilation relationship. [This is where I can use your help] Please note with this example story an observer can view into another space-time dimension!

Anoman and Znoman are identical twins with identical synchronized Cesium Clocks living on opposite sides of a hollow planet along a diameter. Anoman sleeps with his clock on a table on the outside of the planet (1g), while Znoman sleeps with his clock just inside the hollow planet with (0g). Anoman's clock will run slower than Znoman's clock and Znoman will age faster. Now start the planet turning to the point where centripetal acceleration cancels gravitational acceleration on the surface (0g) and you now have (1g) in the interior. Znoman's Clock inside the planet now runs slower than Anoman's clock on the outside and Anoman will age faster.

Thanks, Are these observations valid? Your thoughts and feedback are greatly appreciated; for an old retired Physics/Mathematics college professor on a cold winter day: grandpawo@gmail.com
grandpawo
 
Posts: 1
Joined: Wed Mar 15, 2017 5:48 pm

 

Re: Gravity Angular momentum equivalence

Postby Good Elf » Sat Mar 18, 2017 5:10 am

@grandpawo:

Maths is not required so it is easy to do this myself. It is down to Einstein's Equivalence Principle. Assuming the problem is the first one. I hole burrowed through the center of the planet. Everything else is idealized. Jumping into the hole the traveler will fall initially with the acceleration due to gravity (1 Gee) at the surface. As he continues to fall the acceleration reduces but the velocity increases according to normal kinematics until he reaches the center. At this point the acceleration becomes zero his velocity is at a maximum and "this dog begins to run out of the woods". If he hits the "sides" of the hole he is "toast". As the traveler approaches the opposite surface of the planet from inside his velocity will be undergoing a parametric reduction in speed until his velocity at the surface exactly matches the velocity he had when he entered the hole when he "jumped in".

Next is a "hollow earth" where the entire mass of the earth is concentrated into an infinitely thin shell like a spherical egg shell. the traveler jumps into the hole but because the acceleration is only for an extremely short time his internal velocity and even his final velocity is very small indeed, additionally since it's maximum value is still only 1Gee, he may take many years to float across the gap to the other side. He will probably die of hunger before he reaches his target.

Assuming the "shell" is free to rotate around any axis then if this axis is perpendicular to the tunnel at all times and the acceleration of the shell has taken the centripetal speed to exactly 1 Gee he will be weightless at the outer surface but I advise that he maintain contact because the slightest push will disallow him from ever returning to the surface which is now traveling at several thousands of Km/hr tangentially, if he ever returns he may at best shatter every bone in his body if he has drifted "awkwardly" away from that narrow band of safety because by being in contact with the surface, he has already just about attained "escape velocity" of seven miles per second (40,000 Km/hr), so he should not "sneeze" or move from his present position. Just get into the hole fast and hold on. If rotation is about any other axis I would have serious reservations of jumping into the hole without doing the figures (see below). With a shell and standing on the surface of the shell almost weightless and at speed, he could pull himself against gravity into the hole and jump and he will move away a small distance from the hole towards the center with his feet bouncing on the inner shell at 1Gee. the further away he is from the perpendicular axis of that spin the more difficult things will become for him because he is moving with the inside of the shell at several thousand Km per hr while the poles are at zero km/hr and that polar point is rotating once every couple of hours, so he will experience "Corolis Forces" like being in a Graviton, what you don't do in a graviton is head to the core crawl up and jump... I don't advice that. This is not a graviton unless someone has stupidly deliberately provided a means for self-destruction there. This experience at 1Gee will cause him to feel a little nausea, the inner ear canal will feel "somewhat unnatural" not sensing the "up" direction everywhere correctly, particularly off axis. if he "jumps up" but mostly he will continue to be be safe provided he does not head towards the "poles of rotation", jumping up there may lead to nasty consequences where he may move several thousands of Km into the planet's interior then spiral out towards the inner surface and hit it's surface spinning at 40 thousands of kilometers per hour tangentially. Interesting way to commit suicide though.
Aa' menle nauva calen ar' ta hwesta e' ale'quenle
User avatar
Good Elf
 
Posts: 407
Joined: Fri Oct 29, 2010 12:21 am
Location: Brisbane, Australia


Return to Gravity and Relativity

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests

cron
suspicion-preferred